Pompano Beach & Orlando | Serving Clients Across Florida
Call 24/7: 877-848-5297

THE BURDEN OF PROOF AFTER A FALL

Florida Slip and Fall Claims: How to Prove Notice

By Miller & Jacobs Slip and Fall Attorneys

To prove notice under Florida Statute 768.0755, you must show that the business knew about the temporary substance or should have known about it, and should have acted to fix it. A fall alone does not prove notice or liability.

When this rule applies

You may know what made you slip without knowing when it appeared or who saw it. Start with what you observed, then look for records that fill those gaps. Our  Pompano Beach slip and fall attorneys  can help review that evidence.
A “transitory foreign substance” is a temporary substance, such as spilled liquid or dropped food.  Section 768.0755  addresses falls on these substances at business establishments. It leaves the common-law duties of those who possess or control business premises intact.
A broken stair or other property defect may raise different issues. Our  Pompano Beach premises liability guide  covers the broader subject. A notice finding also leaves other parts of a negligence claim to prove, including breach of duty, causation, and harm.

What did the business know?

Actual knowledge means the business knew of the condition. Constructive knowledge means it should have known. For constructive knowledge, show one of two things. The condition lasted long enough for ordinary care to reveal it. Or it happened regularly and was foreseeable.

Actual knowledge

Look for a report made before the fall. A witness may have seen an employee learn of the spill. A response record may show that staff knew of that same condition.

Keep in mind: An employee standing nearby does not, by itself, establish awareness.

Constructive knowledge: time

Look for signs of when the substance appeared or changed. Marks left by earlier traffic may help place it before your fall.

Keep in mind: Knowing when the business last inspected an area does not tell you when the spill began.

Constructive knowledge: recurrence

Look for earlier complaints, repeated leaks, or repair records tied to the same recurring problem.

Keep in mind: One spill, on its own, does not show a recurring condition.

Match each record to a question

Video: what happened before the fall?

If footage exists, it may show a spill, movement through the area, or a response by staff. Ask about the period before and after the fall, not just the moment you went down.

Its limit: An unclear view does not prove the spill was visible or known. Footage of someone walking past does not prove that either.

Logs: what was checked and when?

Inspection and cleaning records may help compare the business's account with witnesses and video. Check which area was covered, the recorded times, and what staff say they saw.

Its limit: A gap does not prove the spill lasted through that whole period. The claimant still has the burden to prove notice.

Maintenance: did it keep happening?

Complaints and repair records may identify an ongoing source of water or another substance. Compare dates, locations, and descriptions with the condition involved in your fall.

Its limit: A record about another area or a different defect may not support notice of this condition.

What to save while you can

Medical needs come first. If it is safe, use this checklist to keep your observations clear and useful. Photos are one type of evidence; they are not a requirement for every claim.

01

Photograph the scene without changing it.

Take a wide view and closer views of the substance, tracks, nearby signs, and walking area. Keep the original files. Do not move items to make the scene look clearer.

02

Write a timeline from what you know.

Record the location, time, what you saw before and after the fall, and who responded. Separate a witnessed fact from an estimate. Note if cleanup happened before you could take photos.

03

Keep witness and incident details.

Save names and contact details from willing witnesses. Report the fall and keep any report number or copy you receive, along with messages about the incident.

04

Ask promptly about preserving records.

A lawyer can ask to keep useful video, inspection logs and maintenance records. Do not assume cameras exist or that footage is still there. Each business may keep records for a different time.

Miller & Jacobs can review what is known and explain possible next steps. Learn about  partners Mark J. Miller and Rick S. Jacobs, or use our  guide to getting help after an Orlando slip and fall  if that location fits your needs.
A doctor discusses images on a tablet with a patient.

If you keep replaying the walk before a fall, it can be hard to separate what you saw from what you wish you had noticed. Your recovery comes first. You can work through the missing details one at a time.

NEXT STEPS WITH MILLER & JACOBS

Speak With Our Slip and Fall Lawyers

You do not need a full evidence file to start a conversation. Bring the date and place, your account of the condition, and any photos or witness details. Tell us what the business or insurer has said.

The consultation is free and confidential. There is no attorney fee unless compensation is recovered for you, subject to the written representation agreement.

Clues to how long it was there

Clues such as earlier tracks, footprints or drying may help show how long a spill existed. Describe when and where you saw them.

A mark made during your fall, or a substance that was dirty when spilled, may not show earlier notice. Separate what you saw from what you cannot tell.

What people mean by “plus factors”

These are facts beyond the substance’s mere presence. They must help explain how long it was there; the phrase is not a separate statutory shortcut.

Why the full record matters

Welch: more than dirty liquid

In  Welch v. CHLN, Inc. (2023), the evidence included murky liquid and footprints in different directions that the injured person said were not hers. The court found a factual dispute about constructive notice and reversed a ruling that had ended the case before trial.

What the decision means: That ruling allowed the case to proceed. It did not decide that the restaurant was liable.

Safonte: a nearby employee was not enough

In  Publix Super Markets v. Safonte (2024), another customer's yogurt spill existed for about two minutes. A nearby employee had his back to it, and the evidence did not establish that he knew of it. The court found the notice evidence insufficient and directed judgment for Publix.

What the decision means: The decision does not create a two-minute rule for every fall. The circumstances still matter.

Was this a recurring problem?

This route asks whether the same dangerous condition happened regularly, making it foreseeable. Focus on that problem. A general claim that floors sometimes get wet is not enough.

Look for repeated work orders for a leaking cooler. Earlier complaints about water in the same walking area or repeated cleanup may help too. These are records to look for, not findings that this business had notice. A repair record must still connect to the condition that caused your fall.

Evidence preservation and filing deadlines are different.  Section 95.11(5)(a)  sets a two-year limit for negligence actions. The  2023 change  applies to causes of action accruing after its March 24, 2023 effective date. Earlier claims, other claim types, and exceptions need separate review. Have your date checked promptly.

Questions about proving notice

There is no fixed number that decides every case. The question is whether ordinary care should have led the business to discover the condition. Its visibility, duration, and the surrounding facts matter; Safonte applies that fact-specific standard.

No. A pre-fall report or other evidence may show actual knowledge. Constructive knowledge has its own routes through duration or recurrence. Do not treat a denial as proof either way.

That does not automatically resolve your claim. Witness accounts, video, reports, and other records may still help. Record what changed and when. Missing photos do not erase other evidence, but they can leave details harder to establish.