Pompano Beach & Orlando | Serving Clients Across Florida
Call 24/7: 877-848-5297

Florida car accident lawsuits

Can You Sue for a Car Accident?

By Miller & Jacobs Car Accident Attorneys

Yes, you may be able to sue if another party's legal fault caused your losses. What you can claim depends on the loss: car damage, unpaid injury costs or pain and suffering. Florida's no-fault law can limit some injury claims. A suit still needs proof and must be filed on time.

Start by separating what happened, what you lost and which person or policy may be responsible. An insurance claim asks for payment. A lawsuit asks a court to resolve a legal claim.

To discuss your options, Schedule a Free Consultation with our team.

What must the car-crash claim show?

A negligence claim needs proof of a duty of care, a failure to meet that duty, harm caused by that failure and actual losses. The state's civil jury instructions explain negligence and legal cause. More than one person's conduct can contribute to a crash.

Check the lanes and signals

For a turn or light dispute, mark each car's location and what you saw. Compare that sketch with the original footage, photos and witness accounts. A ticket can point to an issue; it does not supply all the proof for court.

Test the injury timeline

Read the first visit note alongside older notes about the same symptoms. What changed after this collision? What was there before? Give the care provider the full history so the claimed link can be checked.

Connect each loss to its records

Put a record next to each amount sought: a repair quote, a pay record or a medical payment statement. Note what is missing. For a future loss, include proof of why you expect it, as well as the estimate.

Check the legal role of each person or business you might name. Driver and car details are leads. Check who owned the car. Find out whether its use was allowed and whether the driver was working. Those facts can point to owner or employer issues. A logo on the car is not proof that a business must pay. A product or road claim needs its own facts.

Separate PIP benefits from the right to sue

Personal injury protection, or PIP, may pay part of covered medical costs and lost income under section 627.736. PIP medical benefits require qualifying initial care within 14 days after the crash. The provider, medical need and other coverage rules also matter. This is separate from the lawsuit deadline. Our steps after a car crash guide covers the first steps for care and records.
PIP benefits and a claim against the responsible party are different. Under section 627.737(1), the no-fault exemption can protect a covered person from paying losses that PIP pays, or would pay except for specified exclusions. A qualifying pain-and-suffering claim can change that protection. Check the required coverage and the kind of loss; the same loss cannot be paid twice.

Where the required no-fault security is in place, section 627.737(2) limits pain, suffering, mental anguish and inconvenience to these injury categories:

Loss of function: Significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function.

Permanent injury: A permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, other than scarring or disfigurement.

Scarring or disfigurement: Significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement.

Death.

The claim and insurance security matter. A permanent injury is not required for every type of loss.

Which coverage fits the claim?

Separate your own policy benefits from a claim that another party owes damages. Liability insurance may fund a covered claim against its insured. A judgment states what is owed; it does not guarantee that insurance or other assets will pay that amount.

If the other driver’s injury coverage is missing or too small, check uninsured or underinsured motorist (UM) coverage. Review who is insured, which vehicle was involved and the complete policy, including signed coverage choices. Do not assume that a UM policy covers every crash.

Missing bodily injury insurance does not necessarily mean the other driver lacks PIP. Section 627.727(7) sets an injury test for UM pain-and-suffering damages, but policy language can provide broader coverage. The Dauksis decision distinguishes the statutory minimum from wider policy terms. Review the required security and the complete policy before deciding which test applies.

What supports the fault figure in the offer?

Ask for the driving act and records behind any fault figure. Under section 768.81, the claimant's own fault reduces damages in the negligence cases the rule covers. More than 50% fault for one's own harm bars damages. At 50%, that bar does not apply. Test the figure against the collision evidence.

The shared-fault change generally applies to suits filed after March 24, 2023. That filing test differs from the accrual test for the shorter negligence deadline below. Chapter 766 medical-negligence cases are excepted from the more-than-50% bar.

Which filing date belongs on your calendar?

Under Section 95.11(5)(a) the usual negligence limit is two years. The 2023 transition law applies that shorter limit to claims accruing after March 24, 2023. Accrual means when a claim legally arises. Older claims and exceptions need a separate check.

A product claim, a claim under your own UM policy or a claim involving a government agency can require a different review of deadlines and notice duties. Check the claim type and proposed defendant before using one date for everything.

An open insurance claim does not, by itself, extend the time to sue. Settlement talks alone do not either. Before filing, ask which parties and court are appropriate and what filing, service and evidence work the lawsuit would require.

Which losses still need proof?

Match disputed losses to their support: damage photos and repair estimates, missed pay and work records, injuries and care history. Keep originals and relevant messages or posts, including material that may hurt the claim.

Treat the crash report as a route to witnesses or other records. Then check the claim's facts. It is not automatic proof of civil fault. Section 316.066(4) limits trial use of a report or statement made by an involved person for the required crash report. Have the evidence rules and exceptions checked for any material you want to use.
Separate car repairs, paid medical bills and unpaid charges. For medical expenses, section 768.0427 affects admissible proof and recovery limits. Future care and lost earning ability need support for the expected loss. Daily-life harm needs its own proof.
Our car crash evidence guide explains how to preserve files. Use the car settlement guide when weighing an offer and possible deductions from payment.
Bring the offer, policies and loss records to our Pompano Beach car accident team. Our Orlando car accident team can assess a crash in that area. These questions for a car accident attorney can help you discuss the work, costs and choices before filing.

If driving again feels harder than expected, a ride to work or a school pickup can become one more part of the day to plan around.

What would accepting this offer close?

What does the offer buy: a resolution of car damage, injury losses or both? Match the payment to the dispute it would end. An agreement may avoid trial. If a supported claim remains open or filing time is close, a suit may be needed. You can negotiate during a suit, but filing does not assure payment.

Compare the release with your claim list. Who would be released? Could the wording include unknown or later injury losses? A label on the check does not settle these questions. Ask how fees and case costs change the net payment. Check medical repayment items too. Broad release wording may end a future claim before the care plan is final.

For an offer that may leave an underinsured motorist claim, the release also affects the UM insurer's right to recover from the driver. Section 627.727(6) has a written notice process so those insurers can consent or protect those rights. Check that process and the policy before the driver's settlement is closed.
Attorney Rick S. Jacobs
Rick S. Jacobs, Partner, Pompano Beach Car Accident Lawyer
Attorney Mark J. Miller
Mark J. Miller, Partner, Car Accident Lawyer

Speak With Our Car Accident Lawyers

Ask which claim may support a suit, what proof is missing and what filing would involve. Discuss the choices, costs and risks before deciding. Mark J. Miller and Rick S. Jacobs are Partners at Miller & Jacobs; no lawyer can promise a favorable result.

For a wrongful-death claim, first confirm who is authorized to file. Under section 768.20, the court-appointed personal representative brings the action for the Act's survivors and estate. A relative does not gain that role just by being family. Check the appointment and death claim's calendar with the wrongful-death filing guide.

Questions about a Florida car accident lawsuit

No. Separate PIP benefits, financial losses and the injury test for pain and suffering. Section 627.737 applies in its no-fault insurance context. A claim still needs proof, and a UM pain-and-suffering claim has separate policy rules that may provide broader coverage.

No. The 14-day requirement concerns qualifying initial care for PIP medical benefits. The general negligence filing period is different. Have the crash date, legal starting point, claim type and any exceptions checked now.

Ask how the fault figure in the offer was reached. Where section 768.81 governs, a claimant's share reduces damages. Responsibility above 50% for one's own harm bars damages; a finding of 50% does not. Check the collision facts behind the proposed figure before using it to make the filing decision.

A lawyer can review the parties, proof, coverage, filing dates and release terms, and explain court steps and costs. Ask which issues remain open and what work is needed. No lawyer can promise the outcome of your case.