Pompano Beach & Orlando | Serving Clients Across Florida
Call 24/7: 877-848-5297

Florida intersection crashes

Who Is at Fault for a T-Bone Accident?

By Miller & Jacobs Car Accident Attorneys

The point of impact does not decide who is at fault. In a T-bone crash, one vehicle hits the side of another. Either driver, or both, may have contributed. Start with the signal or sign for each approach, the drivers' movements and evidence of what happened before impact.

If the accounts conflict, write down what you personally saw and preserve the records you have. A fault review should explain which rule applied, what supports each account and what remains uncertain.

Match each driver's approach to the right rule

Note each street, lane and travel direction. Was the driver turning or going straight? If safe, photograph the signs and lights. Check for a turn arrow or a sign for only one lane. A witness may have seen a different light from the driver.

A circular green light

Under  Florida's traffic-signal law,  a driver facing a green circle may proceed with care. The driver must still yield to vehicles and people lawfully within the intersection or its adjacent crosswalk when green appears. Green does not erase that duty.

A red light generally requires a stop and waiting for green. Some turns are allowed after a stop and yielding, unless a sign bans them. Check the turn and posted signs before calling it an unlawful entry on red.

A left turn or green arrow

Section 316.122  requires a driver turning left to yield to traffic coming from the other direction. This applies when that traffic is in the intersection or close enough to be an immediate hazard. A green circle differs from a green turn arrow. The signal law allows the arrow's turn with care, while still requiring the driver to yield to people and traffic lawfully using the intersection. Check both drivers' lights and when they entered.

A stop sign or uncontrolled entry

A stop is only the first step. Under  the stop-sign rule,  the driver must also yield to traffic in the intersection or close enough to be an immediate hazard. At a four-way stop, the first driver to stop goes first. If drivers arrive at the same time, the one on the left yields to the one on the right.
If no light or sign settles the question, check  Florida's entry rules  and the roads involved. Do not use four-way-stop order for a crash controlled by lights.

An inoperative traffic light

Section 316.1235  requires a stop when a light is not working, under the stop-intersection rules. This also applies to a driver facing a dead light when some other lights still work. Note whether the light was dark, flashing or showing a color. Those are different conditions.

Build a timeline that can test both accounts

Start before the collision, not with the final resting positions. Note where each vehicle approached, when it entered, whether it turned and where contact began. Keep uncertainty visible. If you did not see the other driver's signal, say so.

01

Photographs and witnesses

Save photos of all sides of both vehicles, road markings, sight lines and signs. A close-up of a damaged door does not show the whole approach. Ask witnesses where they stood and which signal they could actually see. Someone who saw impact may not have seen either driver enter.

Make a dated note of your own observations. Separate those from what someone later told you. Keep originals and review our  crash evidence guide  for record and preservation questions.

02

Video and signal records

Look for nearby stores, vehicles or agencies that may hold video. Give the place and a useful time window when asking about it. Ask that the file be kept. Do not assume every camera records or that the file still exists. A request to keep it does not give you a right to obtain it.

Keep the full original clip, not just a screen image or edited part. Check whether its clock matches the real crash time. A signal plan describes how the lights should work. On its own, it does not prove the color at that second. Fault logs or repair records may help test a claim that a light failed.

03

Vehicle data and its limits

If the vehicle may hold crash data, ask which systems were fitted, what files remain and how they can be read. A reconstruction may need other evidence to establish the signal color.

A police report or ticket is part of the review

Obtain the crash report number and check names, location, directions, the diagram and witness information. Our  Florida crash-reporting guide  explains reporting and record questions. If a detail seems wrong, identify it and the supporting record when contacting the investigating agency. Do not rewrite your account to fit a diagram.
A report is not a court judgment assigning civil fault.  Section 316.066(4)  protects certain reports and required reporting statements by people in a crash from use at trial. The law has exceptions. Have the report and other proof reviewed to learn which parts can be used in court.
A ticket is different from proof of the conduct charged.  Section 316.650(9)  restricts use of the citation itself at trial, with narrow exceptions. Under  jury instruction 401.9,  a qualifying traffic-rule violation can be evidence of negligence. It does not settle all questions of fault or cause. Ask which proof can be used.

More than one action can contribute to the harm

A driver may fail to yield while another drives too fast for the conditions. A green light does not excuse unsafe speed.  Section 316.183  requires reasonable speed for the hazards and appropriately reduced speed when approaching and crossing an intersection.
The review must link a claimed failure to the harm. Finding a rule violation is not enough. Florida's  legal-cause instruction  explains that more than one cause can act together. Do not assign fault just from a ticket, a damage photo or one driver's statement.
If current  section 768.81  governs the negligence suit, your share of fault reduces damages by that share. More than 50% fault for your own harm bars recovery under that rule. Exactly 50% reduces damages by half; it does not trigger that bar. An insurer’s proposed share of fault is not a court finding.
The  2023 transition provisions  generally apply the act to suits filed after March 24, 2023. The shorter negligence filing limit instead applies to claims that legally arose after that date. The filing and claim-start dates need separate review. Do not reduce both rules to the date of the crash.

Driver fault and another party's legal responsibility

If a vehicle was borrowed or the driver was working, identify the owner, the employer and the trip’s purpose. Those facts may call for a separate review of who can be named in a claim. Do not treat a business logo as the answer.
A person looking through a window.

If a familiar drive ends in a side-impact crash, uncertainty about what happened can linger after the cars are cleared away.

Attorney Mark J. Miller

Mark J. Miller, Partner

MAKE ROOM FOR WHAT IS STILL UNCLEAR

Talk With Our Intersection Accident Lawyers

Bring the report number, photos, video originals, witness contacts, insurer letters and a short timeline. If an insurer assigns you fault, ask which acts and evidence support it. Identify the point you dispute and any missing record that could resolve it.

For an Orlando collision, an  Orlando car accident lawyer  can review those questions with you. Ask what work is proposed, what evidence may be available and how fees and costs work. Miller & Jacobs can discuss options. A review does not promise a finding of fault or a recovery.
Our  Pompano Beach car accident lawyers  can also discuss a disputed signal, missing records and the basis for an insurer’s fault assessment.

Fault does not by itself establish a payment

Keep care records, work-loss records and repair documents as well as crash evidence. The claim still needs proof of losses and applicable coverage. A fault percentage or policy limit does not set a settlement amount.

Before accepting an offer, ask what it includes and which claims the release would end. Our  settlement guide  explains gross recovery and client net after fees, costs and valid repayments. Request the fee and cost terms and a written distribution estimate.
Have filing dates checked while the fault review is underway. Earlier claims, exceptions and other claim types need their own review. Our  Florida filing-date guide  lists questions to raise. An open claim or settlement talks do not automatically extend a filing deadline.

Questions about a disputed T-bone crash

No. The impact pattern does not establish the signal, right of way or each driver's actions. Either driver, or both, may have contributed. Review the approach and evidence before assigning responsibility.

Identify the lane and signal each driver was facing, including any turn arrow. Compare witness sight lines, original video and available signal records. A statement alone or a timing plan alone may not resolve the conflict.

No. A qualifying traffic violation can be evidence of negligence. It does not decide all questions of fault, cause, loss or coverage. A civil claim needs review of the other facts and proof that can be used.

If current section 768.81 applies to the negligence suit, your share of fault reduces damages. Being more than 50 percent at fault for your own harm bars recovery under that rule. The law that applies and the proof still matter. An insurer's proposed share of fault is not a court finding.