Pompano Beach & Orlando | Serving Clients Across Florida
Call 24/7: 877-848-5297

TBI insurance disputes in Florida

Fighting the Insurance Company After a TBI

By Miller & Jacobs Brain Injury Attorneys

Start with the insurer's written reason for disputing your traumatic brain injury (TBI) claim. Match that reason to the policy, medical records and evidence of what changed after the accident. Keep copies and track deadlines. A diagnosis matters, but it does not by itself prove fault, coverage or the amount owed.

An  Orlando traumatic brain injury attorney  can review a denial, request or proposed release with you. Bring what you have; you do not need a finished claim file to ask for help.
Medical care comes first. After a head injury, a worsening headache, repeated vomiting, seizure or trouble waking calls for urgent help. Call 911 or seek emergency care. See the  CDC's adult danger signs.

Identify the policy and the disputed issue

A claim under a policy that covers you asks for that policy's benefits. You also have duties under the policy. A claim against someone else's liability insurer is different. You must show why that person is legally at fault. Neither route promises payment for every loss.

Coverage

Which policy covers the event and person? Ask for the policy provision behind an exclusion or denial. A claim number does not confirm coverage.

Cause and treatment

Is the insurer disputing the diagnosis, its link to the accident, a particular treatment or a bill? Each issue needs a different response.

Loss and amount

Which expense, missed work or future need is disputed? Separate amounts already documented from estimates that need support.

Florida crash claims may involve personal injury protection (PIP). For PIP medical benefits, you must get qualifying initial care within 14 days of the crash. This rule concerns benefits, not the lawsuit filing deadline. Other rules also limit who is covered, which care qualifies and how much PIP pays. See  section 627.736(1)(a).
Ask which policy applies to each request for a statement, records or an examination. Do not ignore a required response. If you need help understanding the request,  review when legal help may be useful.

Build a timeline when accident causation is disputed

List the accident, first symptoms, first care and later changes in date order. Keep early medical notes, discharge instructions, test reports and follow-up records. Save witness contacts and original photos. The  car accident evidence guide  covers records of the event itself.
The event setting affects the fault and coverage questions. Different records may matter after  car accidents,   bicycle accidents  or  slip and falls.  A  Pompano Beach premises liability claim  may turn on records of a property condition. Match the insurer’s stated issue to the evidence from that event.

Include earlier injuries and symptoms that matter. State what was present before the accident and what is new or worse. Ask your treating clinician to note that history. Explain a gap in care honestly. Do not invent a visit or change an old record.

A scan does not answer every question

The CDC explains that a brain scan is not needed to identify a mild TBI or concussion. A scan may be used to assess a risk of bleeding. Have a clinician explain the actual findings and diagnosis; avoid treating a scan alone as proof that there is, or is not, a concussion. See the  CDC's testing and diagnosis guidance.

A diagnosis addresses your health. Proof of how the accident caused that injury is a separate question. A health page or symptom list does not answer it for your case.

Record cognitive limits with specific examples

TBI can affect attention, memory and planning. The MSKTC guide to  cognitive problems after TBI  describes these difficulties. For a claim, explain what happened during a real task rather than writing only "brain fog" or "a bad day."

Keep a short dated log: the task, what went wrong, how long it lasted and any help you needed. Record better days too. Note missed appointments, reminders, breaks and work changes. Tell your clinician about these issues. A log can support a care discussion. It cannot diagnose a TBI.

For example, a person might lose track of a familiar recipe and need help to finish it. This is an illustration, not a client account. A family member can write what they saw in a separate entry. Name the writer and keep observations separate from guesses.

Keep work schedules, pay records and written job restrictions together. Ask your doctor what work or driving is safe. The  CDC's recovery guidance  calls for written advice on when to return to work and other tasks. Do not stage a difficult task or ignore care instructions to create evidence.

Ask for written explanations you can review later. You may ask to bring a support person, but that person is not automatically authorized to sign or act for you.

Answer a denial or reduction point by point

01

Keep the decision and identify the reason

Save the letter, email or explanation of benefits. Identify the disputed policy term, diagnosis, service date, bill or amount. Ask the insurer to put an unclear explanation in writing. Do not assume every denial means the insurer disputes the whole injury.

02

Match records to the disputed point

A billing error may need a corrected bill from the provider. A treatment dispute may need clinical notes explaining why the care was recommended. An accident-causation dispute may need the before-and-after history. Ask what is missing and where to send it; keep proof of delivery.

If a Florida PIP insurer reduces or denies a claim,  section 627.736(4)(b)2  requires a list of the items it cut or refused to pay. It must give the name and address for your response, and a claim number. This PIP rule does not create one appeal process for all policies.

03

Track the response and get timely review

Keep a contact log with dates, names, requests and promised next steps. Ask whether a review procedure or response deadline applies. Your own coverage may carry cooperation duties. Florida PIP can require an examination under oath and a medical examination; do not treat those as optional merely because the claim is disputed. See  section 627.736(6)-(7).
The  Florida Department of Financial Services consumer assistance service  can help with insurance concerns. It cannot make medical judgments, decide fault or set a claim's value. A consumer complaint is different from filing a lawsuit or a formal bad-faith notice. Do not assume it pauses a court deadline.
Bad faith is a separate legal issue. Florida law says mere negligence alone is not enough, and statutory claims have notice and other requirements. A denial or low offer does not automatically establish bad faith. See  section 624.155.
For Florida negligence claims that accrued after March 24, 2023, the general filing period is two years under  section 95.11(5)(a).  The  2023 law's transition rule  matters for older claims. The date the legal claim arose, the type of claim and any exceptions need review. Policy duties and other claims can have different time limits. Get date-specific advice before waiting for more letters.
A person looking through a window.

If keeping track of the claim has become hard, it is okay to ask for the next step in writing. You can take one disputed point at a time and keep a clear record of what you need answered.

START WITH THE REQUEST IN FRONT OF YOU

Speak With Our Traumatic Brain Injury Lawyers

A lawyer can review the records and dates with you and explain the options. Ask what work the fee agreement covers and how case costs are handled if there is no recovery.

Our  Pompano Beach traumatic brain injury lawyers  can also discuss the insurer’s request or reason with the records you have.

Review the evidence and terms before settling

There is no reliable settlement amount based on a TBI label alone. The useful question is which past losses and future needs the evidence supports, subject to fault, coverage and applicable law.

For motor vehicle claims covered by Florida's no-fault law, pain-and-suffering damages have an injury threshold. This means the injury must fit a category in  section 627.737(2).

The law lists significant permanent loss of an important bodily function. It also lists permanent injury, other than scars or disfigurement, supported to a reasonable degree of medical probability. Significant permanent scars or disfigurement, and death, are the other categories. A TBI diagnosis alone does not establish the threshold.

Before signing, ask which claims and parties the release covers, whether later care is included, and what could reduce the amount you receive. Lawyer fees, case costs and valid medical repayment claims can affect the net amount. The  settlement guide  explains gross and net amounts.

Questions about a disputed TBI claim

No. A scan alone does not answer every medical or legal question. Ask the clinician to explain the findings and diagnosis. The claim still needs evidence linking the injury and losses to the accident.

Start with the stated reason. Send records that answer that point, such as a corrected bill, treatment notes or an accident timeline. Keep copies and proof of delivery. Check the policy and any response deadline.

Yes. They can write dated observations of real events, identify themselves and explain what help was needed. Keep those observations separate from your own notes. The log does not replace a clinical evaluation.

No. Duties depend on the policy and claim. A request from your own insurer can differ from one by the other party's insurer. Get help understanding the request and any deadline before deciding how to respond.