TBI insurance disputes in Florida
Fighting the Insurance Company After a TBI
By Miller & Jacobs Brain Injury Attorneys
Start with the insurer's written reason for disputing your traumatic brain injury (TBI) claim. Match that reason to the policy, medical records and evidence of what changed after the accident. Keep copies and track deadlines. A diagnosis matters, but it does not by itself prove fault, coverage or the amount owed.
Identify the policy and the disputed issue
A claim under a policy that covers you asks for that policy's benefits. You also have duties under the policy. A claim against someone else's liability insurer is different. You must show why that person is legally at fault. Neither route promises payment for every loss.
Coverage
Which policy covers the event and person? Ask for the policy provision behind an exclusion or denial. A claim number does not confirm coverage.
Cause and treatment
Is the insurer disputing the diagnosis, its link to the accident, a particular treatment or a bill? Each issue needs a different response.
Loss and amount
Which expense, missed work or future need is disputed? Separate amounts already documented from estimates that need support.
Build a timeline when accident causation is disputed
Include earlier injuries and symptoms that matter. State what was present before the accident and what is new or worse. Ask your treating clinician to note that history. Explain a gap in care honestly. Do not invent a visit or change an old record.
A scan does not answer every question
A diagnosis addresses your health. Proof of how the accident caused that injury is a separate question. A health page or symptom list does not answer it for your case.
Record cognitive limits with specific examples
Keep a short dated log: the task, what went wrong, how long it lasted and any help you needed. Record better days too. Note missed appointments, reminders, breaks and work changes. Tell your clinician about these issues. A log can support a care discussion. It cannot diagnose a TBI.
For example, a person might lose track of a familiar recipe and need help to finish it. This is an illustration, not a client account. A family member can write what they saw in a separate entry. Name the writer and keep observations separate from guesses.
Ask for written explanations you can review later. You may ask to bring a support person, but that person is not automatically authorized to sign or act for you.
Answer a denial or reduction point by point
01
Keep the decision and identify the reason
Save the letter, email or explanation of benefits. Identify the disputed policy term, diagnosis, service date, bill or amount. Ask the insurer to put an unclear explanation in writing. Do not assume every denial means the insurer disputes the whole injury.
02
Match records to the disputed point
A billing error may need a corrected bill from the provider. A treatment dispute may need clinical notes explaining why the care was recommended. An accident-causation dispute may need the before-and-after history. Ask what is missing and where to send it; keep proof of delivery.
03
Track the response and get timely review
If keeping track of the claim has become hard, it is okay to ask for the next step in writing. You can take one disputed point at a time and keep a clear record of what you need answered.
START WITH THE REQUEST IN FRONT OF YOU
Speak With Our Traumatic Brain Injury Lawyers
A lawyer can review the records and dates with you and explain the options. Ask what work the fee agreement covers and how case costs are handled if there is no recovery.
Review the evidence and terms before settling
There is no reliable settlement amount based on a TBI label alone. The useful question is which past losses and future needs the evidence supports, subject to fault, coverage and applicable law.
The law lists significant permanent loss of an important bodily function. It also lists permanent injury, other than scars or disfigurement, supported to a reasonable degree of medical probability. Significant permanent scars or disfigurement, and death, are the other categories. A TBI diagnosis alone does not establish the threshold.
