What Evidence Might Help My Car Accident Case?

What Evidence Might Help My Car Accident Case?

A car accident can leave victims struggling with painful injuries, from fractures and whiplash to long-term complications that disrupt daily life. Injured victims may also endure financial strain due to medical bills and the inability to work.

If another driver’s negligence caused the crash, you can seek compensation for your losses. However, proving your claim is rarely straightforward. Insurance companies work hard to minimize their financial obligation by downplaying your injuries or rejecting claims.

You should, therefore, work with a legal professional who’ll gather compelling evidence to prove the accident and your losses. A skilled Pompano Beach car accident lawyer has the knowledge and skills to collect, preserve, and present the evidence to insurers and the court.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Proving Fault in a Car Accident: Key Takeaways

• Proving you weren’t at fault requires strong evidence, such as police reports, photos, traffic camera footage, witness testimony, and medical records.
• Multiple parties may be liable in a car accident, including drivers, vehicle owners, employers, and government agencies.
• You can sue for a car accident in cases of severe injuries, disputed liability, bad faith insurers, or uninsured drivers.
• A car accident lawyer strengthens your claim, negotiates with insurers, or litigates for a fair and just settlement.
• Call a car accident attorney to prove negligence and support your claim.

How to Prove a Car Accident Wasn’t Your Fault

Proving a car accident wasn’t your fault protects you from liability and secures the compensation you deserve for damages and injuries.

Successfully establishing the other driver’s responsibility prevents you from being held financially accountable for the collision and strengthens your position when negotiating with insurers.

Here are different sources of evidence to prove the accident wasn’t your fault:

• Police Report: A police report is a source of evidence that documents the details of the accident, including the officers’ assessment of what happened at the scene. The police crash report can provide information regarding the parties involved, the location of the accident, and any citations issued.
• Witness Statements: Eyewitness accounts can strengthen your case by providing independent testimony of how the accident occurred. A car accident attorney can use the contact information of any witnesses at the scene to record their observations about the crash.
• Photographic Evidence: Pictures can give a visual perspective of the car accident. Photos of the accident scene, vehicle damage, skid marks, road conditions, and any visible injuries can help recreate the accident and demonstrate the sequence of events.
• Dashcam Footage: If you have a dashcam installed in your vehicle, the footage can be invaluable in proving the other party’s negligence. Dashcam recordings provide real-time evidence of what transpired before, during, and after the accident.
• Medical Records: You should seek medical attention after the accident, even if you feel fine. Medical records detailing your injuries, treatments, and recovery process can substantiate the extent of harm caused by the collision.
• Expert Analysis: Accident reconstruction experts can evaluate the scene, vehicle damage, and other evidence to create a detailed reconstruction of the accident. Their analysis can clarify how the collision occurred and who was at fault.
• Cellphone Records: If distracted driving is suspected as the cause of the accident, cellphone records can reveal whether the other party was using their phone at the time of the crash. Call logs of the at-fault party can support claims of negligent behavior.
• Maintenance Records: If a vehicle malfunction had a role in the crash, maintenance records can demonstrate whether the other party’s vehicle was in proper working condition. Lack of maintenance or overdue repairs can indicate negligence.
• Traffic Violations: Any traffic citations issued at the scene, such as running a red light or speeding, can be evidence of the other party’s negligent actions. 
• Driver Statements: Statements made by the other driver at the scene or after the crash can help establish fault. Admissions of guilt, apologies, or contradictory statements can tilt your case in your favor.

Who Is at Fault in a Car Accident

Determining fault in a car accident can establish liability, allowing you to pursue compensation for your losses. While many assume only the drivers involved can be at fault, several parties may bear legal responsibility for a car crash.

Here are the parties who may be liable for a crash:

Individual Drivers

The most common liable parties in car accidents are the drivers themselves. A driver can be held at fault for various negligent behaviors, including:

• Speeding
• Running red lights or stop signs
• Texting while driving
• Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs
• Failing to yield the right of way
• Following too closely
• Making illegal turns

When multiple drivers contribute to an accident through negligent actions, fault may be shared based on each party’s degree of responsibility for causing the collision.

Vehicle Owners

Vehicle owners can be liable for the losses even when they weren’t driving during the accident. Liability of vehicle owners occurs when they knowingly allow inexperienced, unlicensed, or intoxicated individuals to operate their vehicles.

Additionally, owners may be responsible if they fail to properly maintain their vehicles in a safe operating condition, such as neglecting brake repairs or allowing bald tires that contribute to the accident.

In some states, vehicle owners are automatically liable for accidents caused by anyone driving their car with permission.

Employers and Companies

Employers can be held responsible for car accidents caused by their employees under the legal doctrine of vicarious liability. The liability arises when employees perform job-related duties, like driving company vehicles or operating within the scope of their employment, at the time of the accident.

Companies may also be liable if they negligently hire drivers with poor driving records, fail to train employees, or pressure drivers to meet unrealistic deadlines that encourage dangerous driving behaviors.

Government Entities

Municipalities, states, and other government agencies responsible for road design and maintenance can be liable when dangerous road conditions contribute to accidents. Government entities may be liable if a crash occurs for the following reasons:

Poorly maintained roadways with potholes or debris

• Inadequate signage
• Malfunctioning traffic signals
• Improperly designed intersections
• Hazardous construction zones without appropriate warnings or traffic control measures.

A car accident attorney can hold a government agency accountable by investigating unsafe road conditions, poor signage, or negligent maintenance. They may use images of the scene, police crash reports, and expert testimony as evidence.

Can I Sue for a Car Accident

Yes, you can sue after a car accident under certain circumstances. While most car accidents are resolved through insurance negotiations, you can sue the negligent party to protect your legal right to compensation.

Litigation provides a fair hearing before an impartial judge and jury. It also allows for a comprehensive assessment of your damages by legal professionals, and can result in better outcomes than settlement offers.

Here are a few reasons to sue after a car accident:

Severe Injuries

One of the most common reasons to sue after a car accident is when you suffer severe injuries. Serious harm, such as traumatic brain injuries or multiple fractures, can lead to long-term medical treatment, rehabilitation, and even permanent disability.

Insurance settlements may not reflect the full extent of these damages, especially when future care or diminished earning capacity is involved. Filing a lawsuit allows you to demonstrate the nature of your losses in court.

A car accident lawyer may advise you to wait for maximum medical improvement (MMI) before initiating a compensation claim. The lengthy trial process allows an injured victim to obtain MMI and understand future medical expenses.

Disputed Liability

In many crashes, the other driver may deny fault or attempt to shift blame onto you. Insurance companies are less likely to pay fair compensation without solid evidence when liability is disputed.

A lawsuit enables a car accident lawyer to gather police reports, accident reconstruction expert testimony, and witness statements to prove who was truly responsible. Taking the matter to court ensures you can present your case before a judge or jury rather than relying on an insurer’s decision.

Insurance Company Bad Faith

Insurance companies must handle claims fairly. However, some engage in “bad faith” practices, such as unnecessary delays, lowball offers, or wrongful denials.

If negotiations break down because of these tactics, suing the insurer may be your only option to secure rightful compensation. A car accident attorney can use a lawsuit to pressure the insurer to pay you a fair settlement value.

The Statute of Limitations is Approaching

Every state has a strict deadline for filing a personal injury lawsuit, known as the statute of limitations. You can lose the right to pursue compensation entirely if you miss this deadline. If your claim is still unresolved and the deadline is near, filing a lawsuit preserves your rights.

The At-Fault Party is Uninsured/Underinsured

If the driver who caused your accident has no insurance or insufficient coverage, you may need to sue them directly. A lawsuit might allow you to access other potential sources of recovery, such as their personal assets or umbrella policies.

A car accident lawyer can also explore your uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage for additional compensation.

Punitive Damages

You can sue for punitive damages when the at-fault driver’s conduct was reckless or intentional, such as driving under the influence, racing, or road rage incidents. A judge or jury can award you punitive damages to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar behavior.

A car accident lawyer can prove reckless driving by presenting evidence like speeding records, eyewitness testimony, or traffic camera footage. With clear proof of disregard for safety, they can increase your chances of receiving punitive damages.

Do I Need a Lawyer for a Car Accident Settlement

You should consider hiring a car accident attorney for settlement negotiations, even if the case doesn’t go to court. They bring valuable experience and knowledge to settlement discussions that can impact the outcome.

Insurance companies often make lowball initial offers, hoping victims will accept inadequate amounts without objections.

An experienced car accident lawyer knows how to calculate your losses, including future treatment costs, diminished earning capacity, ongoing care, and other damages you might overlook.

They understand how to present compelling evidence and negotiate with insurance adjusters trained to minimize payouts. Their presence signals to insurance companies that they may face costly trials, often resulting in higher settlement values than what unrepresented victims receive.

Proving a Car Accident Frequently Asked Questions

Schedule a Free Consultation