When to Get an Attorney for a Car Accident

September 19, 2025 | By Miller & Jacobs Accident Attorneys
When to Get an Attorney for a Car Accident

A car accident can happen in an instant, leaving you with painful injuries, mounting medical bills, and uncertainty about your future. While you may recover compensation for your losses, there is no guarantee of receiving a settlement check.

Insurance companies may minimize payouts, shift blame, or delay processing your claim. You must also demonstrate how the negligent actions of the at-fault party contributed to your losses, making it difficult to get the compensation you deserve.

You should, therefore, speak with a legal professional for guidance after the crash. An experienced car accident lawyer can investigate the crash, gather evidence, and initiate a compensation claim or lawsuit against the negligent party.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Key Takeaways

  • Serious injuries, disputed fault, or uncooperative insurers necessitate legal representation.
  • Attorneys investigate crashes, gather evidence, and negotiate fair settlements.
  • Quick settlement offers often undervalue long-term damages.
  • A car accident attorney can support you if you face wrongful death, permanent disability, or uninsured driver cases.
  • Most attorneys work on contingency, making legal help accessible without upfront costs.
  • Contact a car accident attorney to eliminate the guesswork after a car accident.

When Should You Hire an Attorney for a Car Accident

Deciding whether to hire a car accident attorney can impact your financial recovery and peace of mind. While minor fender-benders with apparent fault might not require legal representation, certain circumstances necessitate professional help.

Here are a few reasons to hire an attorney after a crash:

You Suffered Serious Injuries

Severe injuries requiring hospitalization, surgery, or extended treatment demand professional legal representation. These cases involve substantial medical expenses, lost earnings, and long-term care costs that insurance companies aggressively fight to minimize.

An experienced car accident attorney knows how to calculate the actual value of your claim, including economic and non-economic damages. They work with medical professionals to document the full extent of your injuries and their impact on your life, and fight to maximize your settlement value.

The Fault Is Disputed

Alphabet letter block in word letter block on wood background

You may be confused when the other party denies responsibility or claims you contributed to the accident. Insurance companies will use any ambiguity to reduce or deny your claim.

A car accident attorney has the resources and skills to investigate, gather evidence, work with accident reconstructionists, and build compelling cases that establish clear liability. They understand traffic laws, negligence standards, and how to counter false accusations that can devalue your claim.

The Insurance Company Is Uncooperative

Insurance companies employ various tactics to delay, deny, or minimize claims. For example, they may request excessive documentation, dispute the treatment plan, or make unreasonably low offers.

When insurers act in bad faith, you need a car accident lawyer who understands insurance law and can hold companies accountable. Legal representation often changes the insurance company's approach, as they know attorneys will pursue litigation if necessary.

An insurer will likely make a higher settlement offer if it knows a car accident attorney is advocating on your behalf.

They Offer a Quick Settlement

Early settlement offers are mostly inadequate. Insurers make quick offers before the injured victim understands the full extent of injuries and damages. Insurance companies hope you'll accept quick money rather than wait for a proper medical evaluation.

A car accident lawyer recognizes these tactics and advises clients to complete medical treatment before considering settlements. They will use medical records and other sources of evidence to negotiate with an insurer for a higher settlement value.

The At-Fault Driver Was Uninsured or Underinsured

In most cases, the at-fault party's insurer is the source of compensation for the injured victim. Therefore, the level of insurance coverage can determine how much you receive for your injury-related losses.

A car accident attorney can explore other sources of compensation, including alternative insurance or filing a lawsuit against the negligent party. They understand these policies and can identify all available coverage sources, including umbrella policies, commercial coverage, or personal assets of the at-fault party.

You're Facing Permanent Disability

Permanent disabilities resulting from car accidents require lifetime financial planning and substantial compensation for ongoing care, lost income, home modifications, and reduced quality of life.

A legal professional calculates lifetime costs and presents compelling evidence to insurance companies or juries. An experienced car accident attorney has the knowledge and resources to handle valuation and pursue adequate compensation for permanent impairments.

The Accident Resulted in a Fatality

You should also hire a car accident lawyer if a crash results in the wrongful death of a loved one. A car accident attorney understands your eligibility to file a claim, meet strict legal timelines, and recover unique losses such as loss of companionship.

They understand the unique laws that apply to wrongful deaths, can prove liability, and represent you before an insurer or judge.

Multiple Parties Are Involved

Multi-vehicle accidents create complicated scenarios where several parties share fault. These cases require extensive investigation to determine each party's contribution to the accident and identify all available insurance policies.

A car accident attorney can coordinate with multiple insurance companies, prevent parties from shifting blame, and fight to maximize the settlement value.

How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Lawyer for a Car Accident

Most car accident attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing up front and only owe legal fees if they successfully recover compensation for your case. The arrangement makes professional legal representation accessible to accident victims regardless of their financial situation.

However, several factors influence the cost of hiring a car accident lawyer.

Contingency Fee Percentages

Contingency Fee & Dollar Bills

The standard contingency fee for car accident cases typically ranges from 30 to 40 percent of your total settlement or court award. Simple cases that settle quickly often command fees on the lower end, around 30 percent, while complex cases requiring extensive litigation may reach 40 percent.

Some attorneys use a sliding scale where the percentage increases if the case goes to trial, reflecting the additional time and resources required for courtroom proceedings.

Case Complexity and Duration

More complex cases generally result in higher legal costs. Multi-vehicle accidents, disputed liability, serious injuries requiring professional testimony, or cases involving commercial vehicles demand extensive investigation, expert witnesses, and prolonged negotiations.

These factors can increase the contingency percentage or add expenses that reduce your net settlement amount.

Geographic Location

Legal fees also vary by region. Legal fees often vary by region. Factors like local court procedures, firm overhead costs, and market competition all influence what attorneys in a particular city or state may charge. The local market competition, cost of living, and typical case values in your area all influence pricing.

Urban markets often see more competitive rates due to the abundance of attorneys, while attorneys who deal with a unique field in certain regions may command premium fees.

Attorney Experience and Reputation

An attorney's fee can reflect their background, the resources their firm offers, and their overall approach to handling injury cases. When choosing an attorney, consider their communication style, strategy, and whether you feel comfortable with them. The goal is to find representation that you trust to handle your case effectively.

Additional Expenses

Beyond contingency fees, you may be responsible for case expenses such as filing fees, expert witness costs, medical record retrieval, accident reconstruction services, and court reporting fees.

A car accident lawyer can absorb and deduct these costs from your settlement, while others require upfront payment. Clarify expense policies during your initial consultation to avoid surprises.

Settlement vs.Trial

Cases that settle out of court typically involve lower total costs than those requiring trial litigation. Court proceedings generate additional expenses, including jury fees, extended attorney time, and professional testimony costs.

A car accident attorney may adjust their contingency percentages based on whether a settlement occurs before or after filing a lawsuit.

Negotiation Opportunities

Don't assume contingency fees are non-negotiable. A car accident lawyer may be willing to adjust their percentages for clear liability cases, clients with strong cases, or those with significant damages.

However, remember that the lowest fee doesn't always provide the best value if it comes with inexperienced representation. Focus on the net amount you'll receive rather than just the service fee of a car accident lawyer.

How Much Can Someone Sue for a Car Accident

There is no average value you can sue for a car accident. The outcome depends on the facts and circumstances of the crash. Here are the factors that influence the value of your claim:

Severity and Type of Injuries

Man with inflamed spinal cord injury pain highlighted in glowing red.

The extent of your injuries serves as the primary driver of lawsuit value. Minor soft tissue injuries may result in settlements of a few thousand dollars. In contrast, catastrophic injuries like traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord damage, or permanent disabilities can generate awards exceeding millions.

A car accident lawyer can demonstrate current medical expenses, future treatment costs, and rehabilitation needs to maximize your settlement value.

Pain and Suffering

You also deserve compensation for non-economic damages for physical pain, emotional distress, and diminished quality of life as a result of the injury. These subjective damages vary widely based on injury severity, recovery duration, and how the accident impacts daily activities and relationships.

At-Fault Party's Insurance Coverage

Insurance limits cap your potential recovery regardless of actual damages. While you can pursue the defendant's assets beyond insurance limits, most people lack sufficient wealth to pay judgments.

Underinsured drivers may leave victims with substantial uncovered losses despite clear liability.

Available Evidence and Fault Determination

Strong evidence proving clear liability increases settlement values, while disputed fault or weak evidence typically reduces awards. Video footage, witness testimony, and professional reconstruction can impact negotiations and trial outcomes.

A car accident lawyer can use evidence to enhance your position while negotiating with insurers or in court.

Geographic Location

Prevailing jury tendencies, cost of living, and typical award amounts vary by region. Urban areas often see higher settlements than rural jurisdictions. Some states have damage caps, which can limit how much you receive for your losses.

Skilled legal representation plays a crucial role in the outcome of a claim. An attorney can build a strong case, document your damages thoroughly, and negotiate effectively with insurance companies to protect your interests. They can fight for a better outcome through skilled negotiation, thorough case preparation, and a willingness to pursue a trial.

Let an Experienced Lawyer Fight for What You Deserve

Your quality of life is likely to worsen after sustaining an injury in a crash caused by someone else’s negligence. For instance, an amputated arm after a car crash can prevent you from participating in bowling, your favorite activity.

You may also experience worsening mental health, necessitating treatment programs like medication or therapy. A car accident lawyer gathers compelling evidence, challenges insurers, and litigates to secure a fair and just settlement.

Contact a car accident lawyer after a crash to protect your right to compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Do I Have to File a Claim or Lawsuit?

The statute of limitations for car accident claims varies by state, typically one to six years. However, you should initiate an insurance claim sooner, often within days or weeks.

Missing these deadlines can bar your right to compensation. An experienced car accident lawyer understands the applicable deadlines and initiates timely claims to protect your right to compensation.

What if I Was Partially at Fault for the Accident?

You can recover compensation under shared liability laws even if partially at fault. Your degree of fault will reduce the settlement value by a similar percentage. If you're 30 percent responsible for a $100,000 claim, you receive $70,000.

However, some states bar recovery if you're 50 percent or more at fault. A car accident lawyer can use evidence to protect you from being unfairly blamed for the crash.

Do I Have to Speak With the Insurance Adjuster?

You're only required to cooperate with your own insurance company. You have no legal obligation to speak with the other party's adjuster, who works to minimize their company's payout. An insurer can use your words against you later.

Instead, let a car accident attorney handle all communications with opposing insurance companies. They can also evaluate any settlement offer and advise whether to accept or negotiate for a better deal.

What evidence should I try to collect at the accident scene?

If you are physically able, gather as much information as possible. Use your phone to take photos and videos of the vehicles, their positions, skid marks, property damage, and the surrounding area. Exchange contact and insurance information with the other driver(s), get contact details from any witnesses, and write down the responding police officer's name and badge number.

Should I see a doctor after a car accident even if I don't feel hurt?

Yes, you should always seek a medical evaluation after a car accident. Some serious injuries, like whiplash or internal bleeding, may not show immediate symptoms.

A medical report creates an official record linking your injuries to the crash, which you need for your insurance claim or lawsuit.

Delaying treatment may give the insurance company a reason to argue your injuries are not accident-related.

What records should I keep after a car accident?

Keep a detailed file of all accident-related documents. This includes the police report, medical bills, receipts for prescription drugs, and records of any other out-of-pocket expenses.

Document your missed time from work and keep a journal detailing your physical pain, emotional distress, and how the injuries affect your daily life.

Schedule a Free Consultation